OVERWHELM

Price Rationale

OVERWHELM is an August 2019 SuperRare XCOPY 1/1 with two clean exact-token sales: 0.85 ETH / $159.83 on 2019-08-21 and 0.95 ETH / $174.45 on 2019-11-15, with alotta.eth holding since that last sale. The supplied packet has no current ask, best bid, OTC sale, grail flag, or outgoing candidate benchmark, so current fair value cannot lean on live demand. I give meaningful credit for early SuperRare XCOPY scarcity and long-term clean provenance, and I treat the sub-1 ETH 2019 prints as stale pre-repricing evidence rather than a current ceiling. The comparable, cultural, and ETH-cycle appraisers converge around 42-45 ETH, while the liquidity appraiser's 22 ETH mark is best read as an executable-exit haircut rather than full fair value. A 42 ETH fair value with a 24-66 ETH bid/ask range balances that consensus with thin token-specific liquidity.

What Caps The Price

A materially higher mark would import value from stronger or more recently validated XCOPY 1/1s without enough token-specific evidence. OVERWHELM has no live bid, no ask, no OTC history, no grail flag, no candidate benchmark set, and no post-2019 sale; the only exact-token trades remain 0.85 and 0.95 ETH from 2019. That rules out treating higher later-cycle XCOPY marks as directly transferable.

What Supports The Price

The 2019 sale ladder is too stale to anchor current value near 1 ETH. This is still a genuine 2019 SuperRare XCOPY one-of-one with clean provenance, two early onchain sales, and long-term single-holder custody. The broader supplied XCOPY 1/1 snapshot shows many early works repriced far above original-era sales, so absent current bids should be treated as liquidity uncertainty rather than evidence of negligible collector demand.